Light, Ni, Schambra, Salamon, and Frumkin
Not exactly! On February 20, 2009, The Hudson Institute’s Bradley Center for Philanthropy and Civic Renewal and The Nonprofit Quarterly presented a knowledgeable and lively panel discussion about an article by Paul Light titled “Four Futures”, which appeared in the Winter 2008 issue of The Nonprofit Quarterly. The session was moderated by the Bradley Center’s William Schambra, and panelists included:
- Paul Light, New York University
- Perla Ni, Great Nonprofits
- Peter Frumkin, University of Texas Austin
- Lester Salamon, Johns Hopkins University
Rick Cohen from The Nonprofit Quarterly welcomed the group and offered some observations on the stimulus package and what it might do for nonprofits. He posited that the real question about the stimulus package should be not what effect it would have on nonprofits but what impact it would have on the communities they serve.
Paul Light outlined four possible scenarios for nonprofits: the rescue fantasy, a withering winter land, an arbitrary winnowing, and transformation. Each of the panelists then reacted to the scenarios. Ni felt that smaller nonprofits would survive the crisis because they could be more flexible and had compelling stories. Salamon commented that in the proposed scenarios, nonprofits were acted upon, and he felt that there is resilience in the sector that will enable it to save itself. Frumkin shared his concerns about the four funding streams for nonprofits: earned income, individual giving, government funding, and foundations and corporations. He then shared his theory that nonprofits who have been using the “rhetoric of reason and rationale” may begin using the “rhetoric of emotion” to maintain and attract donors. This issue sparked a lively discussion about how to measure a nonprofit’s value. Do we give with our heads, our hearts, or both? In the end, the panelists believed that nonprofits would adapt and survive.
An audio and video recording of this event will be posted at the Bradley Center's web site shortly after the event. A transcript of the discussion will be posted approximately one week after the event.
This post is from Pat Pasqual, director the Foundation Center's library/learning center in Washington, D.C.